Sarah sat in her chair, staring at the glowing spreadsheet until the cells began to blur into a gray haze. On paper, she was a “Senior Marketing Coordinator.” In reality, she was the engine room of the department. She managed the vendor relationships, wrote the copy that converted, and as of three months ago was quietly absorbing the duties of a departed director.
Then came the coffee break that changed everything.
A casual conversation with a peer from a competing firm revealed a startling gap. While Sarah was negotiating for better brand deals for her company, she had failed to negotiate for herself. She was earning 20% less than the industry average.
The feeling hit her like a physical weight: a mix of resentment, embarrassment, and a sudden exhaustion.
Hey Street squad! If you’ve finally left the street and now in suit – what we love, and at some point you’ve felt being present but completely undervalued, let’s see how Sarah move from underpaid to empowered.
Phase 1: The Reality Check
Before Sarah could storm into her boss’s office, she had to move past the feeling and get to the facts. Resentment is a powerful motivator, but data is a powerful closer.
She made market research using sites like Glassdoor and Payscale, but she didn’t stop there. She reached out to recruiters on LinkedIn to ask what live roles were currently offering.
She realized she hadn’t updated her list of accomplishments in a year. She sat down and quantified her impact.
She printed her original job description and highlighted everything she was doing that wasn’t on the page.
The Lesson: You cannot ask for more based on need or fairness. You ask based on the market value of the problems you solve.
Phase 2: The Mental Shift
For a week, Sarah struggled with Imposter syndrome. She wondered if she was being greedy. She had to shift her mindset from asking for a favor to conducting a business transaction.
“If my company was overpaying a vendor for a service that didn’t work, they would cut them in a heartbeat,” she realized. This is just the reverse. I am a vendor of my time and talent, and I am currently undercharging my client.
She decided on a walk-away point. If the company couldn’t meet her at a fair number, she wouldn’t quit tomorrow, but she would commit 100% of her extra energy to a job search.
Phase 3: The Conversation
Sarah scheduled a meeting with her manager. She didn’t title the calendar invite “I need a raise.” Instead, she titled it “Role Review and Strategic Growth Discussion.” When the meeting began, she didn’t lead with her bank account. She led with her commitment.
“Mark, I love the work we’re doing on the… Over the last six months, my role has evolved significantly to include director-level strategy and vendor management.”
“I’ve done some benchmarking to ensure my compensation aligns with these new responsibilities and the current market. Based on my contributions, specifically the 15% cost savings I’d like to discuss adjusting my salary to $X.”
After she stated her number, she did the hardest thing possible: She stopped talking. She let the silence sit until Mark spoke.
Phase 4: Handling “No” or “Not Now”
Mark didn’t say yes immediately. He sighed and mentioned budget cycles and company-wide freezes.
Sarah was prepared, she didn’t get angry. She pivoted to Variable Compensation and Non-Monetary Benefits.
The Counter-Offer: “I understand the budget constraints for this quarter. If we can’t hit that base salary today, can we look at a performance-based bonus tied to the Q3 targets? Or, perhaps, we could discuss a four-day work week or a stipend for the professional certification I’m finishing?”
She asked for a clear timeline. “What specific milestones do I need to hit to reach this salary by the next review cycle? Let’s get those in writing.”
Phase 5: The Pivot
Know your worth then go find it. Two months later, the budget freezeremained, but Sarah’s workload didn’t. She realized that her current company’s ceiling was her floor.
She didn’t slack off, she remained a professional but she redirected her above and beyond energy toward her own career. She polished her portfolio, practiced her interviewing skills, and stopped staying late to fix other people’s mistakes.
Within six weeks, Sarah had two offers. Both were for more than the number she had asked Mark for.
If you’re standing where Sarah stood, follow these steps:
Gather Your “Receipts”: List every project you’ve touched that made or saved the company money.
Benchmark Broadly, don’t just look at one website, talk to peers and recruiters.
Don’t wait for your annual review. If your role has changed, the conversation should happen now.
Practice Your Script. Say your desired number out loud until it sounds like a fact, not a question.
If the answer is a “no,” your value hasn’t decreased, your location just needs to change.
Conclusion
Sarah ended up taking a role at a mid-sized firm that valued her extraskills from day one. On her last day, Mark told her they’d miss her. She smiled, thanked him, and walked out.
Feeling underpaid isn’t just about the money. It’s about the erosion of your professional spirit. You aren’t a ghost in the machine. You are the talent that makes the machine run. If the current shop won’t pay for the maintenance, it’s time to take your tools elsewhere. And if your CV needs an update, let Street2suit handle it professionally for you.
Receive the latest job and career updates in your inbox, every week!
Mariam is an imaginative and meticulous writer who is passionate about crafting compelling narratives and translating concepts into influential content.
